May 2024 Top 414 Dynasty Baseball Rankings (Patreon)

Welcome to May Dynasty Baseball Rankings Week! Unlike the April Update, we have a legit sample to work with to make some real determinations. As usual, I will be going over 400 deep with blurbs for every player. Top 20 is free here on the Brick Wall. Here is the May 2024 Top 414 Dynasty Baseball Rankings:

CLICK HERE TO JOIN MY PATREON FOR THE REST OF THESE RANKINGS & TONS OF EXCLUSIVE CONTENT ALL SEASON, INCLUDING:
-MAY TOP 414 DYNASTY BASEBALL RANKS (5/24/24)
-MAY TOP 301 PROSPECTS RANKS (5/10/23)
-HALP’S DYNASTY BASEBALL PODCAST: MAILBAG!
-TONS OF DYNASTY RUNDOWNS
-SPREADSHEETS

*Off-season and April rankings are in parenthesis, in that order

1) (9) (9) Elly De La Cruz – CIN, SS/3B, 22.4 – I went all in on Elly’s insane upside this off-season, ranking him 9th overall on the Top 1,000 and writing, “I always say, ‘if you can’t take risks in fantasy, where can you take risks,’ and I’m not even sure Elly is as risky as people think. I’m all in.” … And now that he’s exploded with a legit shot at 30/100, I’m not taking my foot off the pedal. He’s still a bit riskier than some of the elite talent ranked after him, but none of them can touch his upside. He’s my #1 overall dynasty player.

2) (2) (2) Bobby Witt Jr. – KCR, SS, 23.11 – Witt’s cooled off a bit from the scorching start to the season with a .867 OPS, but the underlying numbers are still elite with a .404 xwOBA. I was so close to ranking him over Elly as the top dog because he definitely has the safer hit tool, but I didn’t play it safe with Elly this off-season, and I’m not going to start now

3) (4) (5) Shohei Ohtani – LAD, RHP/DH, 29.10 – Ohtani doesn’t even need to pitch to be the most valuable player in fantasy, ranking 1st overall on the Razzball Player Rater. If he comes back healthy on the mound in 2025, he’s such an insanely good win now piece that I just can’t ding him for being older than the other elite players. He was my undisputed #1 overall dynasty player before going down with the elbow injury, and there is an argument that he should still hold that top spot

4) (1) (1) Ronald Acuna Jr. – ATL, OF, 26.4 – We’re deep enough into the season to say something ain’t right. The elite contact numbers from 2023 have completely disappeared, and the 8.9% Barrel% is a career low by far. He’s been unlucky (.322 wOBA vs. .353 xwOBA), and he’s still crushing the ball (92.4 MPH EV), so I do think a heater is coming, but this has gone beyond a slow start to the season. He deserves a small drop, but this is still an elite of the elite dynasty asset for me.

Shadow4) (10) (13) Shohei Ohtani – LAD, DH only/Weekly Leagues, 29.10 – This is where I would rank Ohtani in weekly leagues or as a hitter only

5) (7) (7) Juan Soto – NYY, OF, 25.7 – As I expected, he’s aiming for that short porch, increasing his pull percentage 6.9 percentage points to a career high 45.8% and increasing his launch 3.7 degrees to 10.4 degrees. It’s resulted in 11 homers and a .463 xwOBA (2nd best in baseball behind only Ohtani) in 48 games. The 4 steals are modest, but that actually puts him on a career high pace there too

6) (13) (28) Gunnar Henderson – BAL, SS/3B, 22.10 – Well, well, well. How the turntables … have turned. I ranked Gunnar over Carroll as the #1 overall prospect in the game in the 2023 Rankings, and that looked like a mistake after the 2023 season, but things look different this year with Gunnar jumping back over Carroll. His 94.1 MPH EV is in the top 3% of the league, and it’s led to 16 homers, which leads the league. And he’s running much more with 7 steals. I wouldn’t be surprised if this isn’t the last time Carroll and Gunnar flip values, but right now, Gunnar reigns supreme.

7) (8) (8) Kyle Tucker – HOU, OF, 27.3 – 15 homers is the 2nd most in the league behind Gunnar, and his 192 wRC+ is 2nd to only Ohtani … and it still feels like barely anyone gets excited about him. It’s crazy how good he is compared to his hype

8) (11) (12) Aaron Judge – NYY, OF, 32.0 – Unsurprisingly shook off a slow start with 10 homers and a 1.307 OPS in his last 25 games. The exit velocity king is back atop his throne with a 96.6 MPH EV that leads all of baseball

9) (12) (14) Mookie Betts – LAD, 2B/OF, 31.7 – 185 wRC+ is tied for a career high, and his 8 steals in 48 games is on pace to shatter his recent season steal totals

10) (3) (6) Fernando Tatis Jr. – SDP, OF, 25.4 – Only 6 steals in 7 attempts is the main thing holding him back from ranking higher. His EV also hasn’t really bounced back to pre PED/wrist/shoulder levels, but Tatis is still an elite beast with a .389 xwOBA that is in the top 6% of the league.

11) (6) (4) Julio Rodriguez – SEA, OF, 23.4 – Julio is a notorious slow starter and nothing looks too concerning in the underlying numbers. He’s already started to heat up with a .315 BA in his last 31 games. The homer binge has to be around the corner

12) (5) (3) Corbin Carroll – ARI, OF, 23.8 – It’s getting harder to keep the faith, but a 92 MPH EV in May tells me better days are still ahead. He’s also definitely been unlucky with a .251 wOBA vs. 305 xwOBA. We might be entering prime buy low territory right now

13) (10) (10) Yordan Alvarez – HOU, OF, 26.7 – With nearly zero value in the stolen base category, Yordan needs to be air tight elite everywhere else, and he hasn’t been this year with a .759 OPS. The underlying numbers are better, but even those are in career low areas with a still very good 12.8% Barrel% and .373 xwOBA

14) (15) (46) CJ Abrams – WAS, SS, 23.7 – Cooled off since the hot start, but Abrams is still showing major improvement with a 89.1 MPH EV, .374 xwOBA, and .310 xBA. He hasn’t locked in his near elite dynasty asset status, but he’s clearly leveling up

15) (16) (43) Anthony Volpe – NYY, SS, 23.0 – Leveled off after the scorching start, but the hit tool is clearly much improved with a .270 BA and 21.3% whiff% (.209 BA with a 28.1% whiff% in 2023), and the power/speed combo is still very good with a 20/30 season within reach

16) (17) (13) Bryce Harper – PHI, 1B, 31.7 – Career low by far 26.4 ft/sec sprint shows there could be some physical decline here, and a .360 xwOBA is nearly a career low. It’s way too early to say he’s declining and the 146 wRC+ is near elite, but I think it’s worth mentioning

17) (18) (15) Jose Ramirez – CLE, 3B, 31.7 – .302 xwOBA is basically a career low and his OPS is on a 4 year decline at .780. Like Harper, it’s worth mentioning, but he still ranks 12th overall on the Razzball Player Rater and nothing is overly concerning in the underlying numbers, so way too early to say it’s the start of a decline phase

18) (19) (17) Trea Turner – PHI, SS, 30.10 – Out since May 3rd with a hamstring strain. He wasn’t showing any signs of decline before going down with the injury with a .343 BA, 2 homers, and 10 steals in 33 games

19) (78) (106) Paul Skenes – PIT, RHP, 21.11 – Called up the bigs and hasn’t missed a beat with a 2.70 ERA and 46.2%/7.7% K%/BB% in 10 IP. The fastball sits 99.7 MPH and he has a 38.3% whiff%. Calling Skenes a generational pitching prospect was not oversold. It might be early, but I don’t think I would trade Skenes for any other pitcher. He’s my new top dog dynasty baseball pitcher

20) (42) (59) Tarik Skubal – DET, LHP, 27.5 – Not only is he backing up the 2023 breakout, he’s actually been even better with a 1.80 ERA and 31.6%/3.8% K%/BB% in 55 IP. The velocity is up too with a 96.6 MPH fastball. He’s the best starter in baseball. Just stay healthy

By Michael Halpern (@MichaelCHalpern)
Email: michaelhalpern@imaginarybrickwall.com
Twitter: Imaginary Brick Wall (@DynastyHalp)

Share this:

Related