Yuki Matsui – Imaginary Brick Wall

As usual, I’m doing Dynasty Baseball Rundowns all Spring, with most of them coming on the Patreon, and a few coming on the Brick Wall like this one (usually on Monday’s, but I’ll make an exception for Spring Training Opening Day). Along with the Rundowns, I have the Top 10 2025 FYPD Rankings, Predicting the Top 50 2025 Prospects Rankings, and an only 2024 Prospects Rankings coming soon on the Patreon. Plus so much more that is already up there, but first, here is the Spring Training Opening Day Dynasty Baseball Rundown:

CLICK HERE TO JOIN MY PATREON FOR TONS OF EXCLUSIVE CONTENT ALL OFF-SEASON & SEASON, INCLUDING:
-TOP 1,000 2024 DYNASTY BASEBALL RANKINGS
-TOP 500 2024 PROSPECTS RANKINGS
-TOP 132 2024 FYPD RANKINGS (+Target & Strategy Guide)
-POSITION BY POSTION TARGET ARTICLES
-OBP TOP 450 DYNASTY RANKS
-6+CATS/PTS/OPS “UNIVERSAL TOP 450 DYNASTY RANKS
-HALP’S DYNASTY BASEBALL PODCAST
-ALL-IN-ONE RANKINGS SPREADSHEET

Yuki Matsui SDP, Closer Committee, 28.5 – And our first Spring Training hype train has officially left the station. Matsui struck out the rusty Gavin Lux coming off major knee surgery with his career .587 OPS vs. lefties, followed up by doing the same to journeyman Chris Owings and his fearsome .650 career OPS, and then finally victimized the rusty Andy Pages coming off major shoulder surgery and his total of 4 PA above Double-A. What’s next, does Matsui want to strikeout my 72 year old father coming off double hip surgery? Then I’ll really be impressed. I’m only half kidding, because there is no denying he looked absolutely filthy out there. The lack of huge velocity doesn’t look like it’s going to be a problem, although crowning him after facing competition that was probably worse than he faced in Japan seems silly. Let’s see him against some legit MLB bats before we hand him the closer job, but having said that, if I’m Robert Suarez, I’m realizing I’m going to have to go out there and win that job. Considering one is a lefty and one is a righty, we seem headed for the dreaded committee right now.

Gavin Lux LAD, 2B/OF, 26.4 – Speaking of Gavin Lux, he genuinely looked completely lost up there vs Matsui, and looking at that career .587 OPS vs. lefties, I might be questioning how long LA is going to throw him out there vs. them. He got a base knock going back up the middle vs. a righty, and went 1 for 2 with a 1/1 K/BB on the day, so it was a good first game back overall, but it would be nice to see some decent at bats versus lefties this spring, or else I think he’s headed for a strong side of a platoon role.

Luis Campusano SDP, C, 25.6 – Luis Campusano’s new batting stance looks like the one they forced on the worst kid on your little league baseball team. He’s choked up halfway up the bat, which he combined with an open face stance and an insane leg kick. He literally never sets into hitting position before the pitch is thrown. He does a balancing act on one leg mid pitch to straighten out his body. I’ve never seen anything like it quite frankly. I already wasn’t super high on Camp, and this just cements my stance that he is not one of the young catchers I’m going after. I’m staying far away.

Joe Musgrove SDP, RHP, 31.4 – Me and Musgrove both pitched 0.0 innings in this game, but I didn’t give up a single earned run. Musgrove gave up 4 earned runs with 2 hits, 1 walk and 0 K’s. Especially for a vet like Musgrove, your first spring training outing is meaningless, but considering his 2023 season ended with a shoulder injury, it would have been nice to see him looking better than this. Obviously it’s way way way too early to panic, but if you were hoping to check off the “Musgrove looks completely healthy” box early in spring, you are going to have to wait.

Jackson Merrill SDP, SS, 20.11 – San Diego had Merrill out in LF, and there is talk of him breaking camp as their starting left fielder. There is nothing MLB teams love more than having a guy play one position his entire career, and then right as they are about to face the biggest challenge of their baseball lives, just throw them in a completely new position like a fish out of water. It’s mind boggling to me. If you didn’t think he was going to play SS for you on the MLB level, why wasn’t he given a shitload more time working on his ultimate position in the minors? Getting used to a new position (especially going from SS to LF) takes time and experience. It’s insane to move someone off their lifelong position right as they are about to get called up to the majors. And it’s a great way to get someone hurt. He didn’t look bad out there, and he’s a great athlete so I don’t think he’s going to be a bumbling fool at the position, but here he is making an awkward diving catch. I honestly don’t know if that play should impress me, or concern me. Here he is taking a circuitous route to catch a ball hit over his head. He made the play, but not pretty.

Andy Pages LAD, OF, 23.4 – Pages looks completely healthy coming off the shoulder surgery, and he smoked a ball the opposite way for his first spring hit, going 1 for 3 with 2 K’s on the day. He’s on his way to getting his hype back rolling, and he’s also on the precipice of a callup when LA needs OF reinforcements.

Gavin Stone LAD, RHP, 25.6 – Stone is ready to bounce back from a poor 2023, and he took the first step throwing a perfect inning with 1 K. The changeup is in mid-season form and he was hitting his spots with his fastball. He only attempted one slider, and it was a horrific, dinky hanger. It might be tough for him to really thrive against MLB hitters without a good breaking ball, and based on that one pitch, he hasn’t perfected it yet.

Ethan Salas SDP, C, 17.10 – The 17 year old Ethan Salas is in camp with the big league club, and he struck out in each of his 2 at bats. Is this just child abuse at this point? Why is San Diego so hellbent on rushing this literal underage child to the big leagues? Aren’t there labor laws on the books for something like this? Or does San Diego know he’s secretly already 25 years old or something? That would at least make it make sense.

By Michael Halpern (@MichaelCHalpern)
Email: michaelhalpern@imaginarybrickwall.com
Twitter: Imaginary Brick Wall (@DynastyHalp)